Don Giovanni at Livermore Valley Opera
March 02, 2025
* Notes *
Livermore Valley Opera's Don Giovanni (Ovation pictured, photograph by author) opened last night at the Bankhead Theater. The opera is cast well and the production is very committed.
Robert Herriot's staging used video projections that featured monstrous roses in every scene. They seemed to have blood vessels and looked almost three-dimensional. The action all was well-motivated, the threats of violence seem very real. The Act I finale had pistols in it so that it made sense that Don Giovanni was able to be cornered and then his escape once he had gotten in control of weapons also was believable. The video projections and stripped down set made for easy scene changes.
Mozart leaves the orchestra exposed and every false start or intonation error was on full display under Maestro Alexander Katsman, especially since there are so few people in the pit. It was all very lively and certainly there was never a dull moment.
The three sopranos in the cast were all quite powerful singers. Meryl Dominguez has such a strong voice as Donna Anna. Cara Gabrielson has a sharper edge to her sound but this works well for Donna Elvira, who does seem somewhat hysterical. I was most partial to Phoebe Chee's Zerlina, she's sweet but also sassy, and has a nice rounded warmth.
Our leading man, baritone Titus Muzi III, embodies Don Giovanni beautifully, even though he hurt his right knee in rehearsal and had to use a cane for the prima. He moves well and looks quite dashing. His voice is not entirely resonant through his whole range. His Champagne aria felt rushed and not perfectly sparkling but his serenade in Act II was lovely.
Tenor David Walton was convincing as Don Ottavio, as was bass-baritone Samuel J. Weiser as Leporello. Walton sounded very pretty, while Weiser has a distinct vibrato. Bass-baritone Joseph Calzada made the most of his small role, his Masetto was charming. Best of all was bass Kirk Eichelberger, his Commendatore was commanding. His low notes are rich and full, and his last scene at dinner when he asks Don Giovanni to repent is terrifying.
*Tattling *
There was a lot of talking during Act I and much crackling of plastic in Act II. At least no electronic noises were noted, and not too much coughing.
I was introduced to mezzo-soprano Frederica von Stade, who is the most famous resident of the city I live in. She liked my outfit and also shared a chocolate chip cookie with me. She was there for the Young Musicians Choral Orchestra, who performed in the lobby before the opera.